Ethiopian Women Face Widespread Online Hate and Exclusion

Online hate speech is pushing Ethiopian women to the margins, investigation reveals

Women and girls in Ethiopia are being excluded from public life, and routinely dismissed and ridiculed in the online space.

These are the findings of new research carried out by the Centre for Information Resilience (CIR), an independent non-profit organisation that focuses on human rights violations, countering disinformation, and combating online violence.

The research expands CIR’s previous analysis of gendered abuse on Facebook, X, and Telegram in Ethiopia, to two additional popular platforms: YouTube and TikTok.

It reveals that online hate speech is limiting who gets to speak, lead, and exist safely in digital spaces, pushing Ethiopian women to the margins.

CIR documented widespread attacks on women’s dignity and worth, messages implying women’s inferiority, and degrading stereotypes.

Women who challenge social norms, including those in leadership roles or women’s sports, were sexualised, discredited, and faced stigmatisation and insults.

But the effects of hate speech go far beyond the individual harm, creating a chilling effect that discourages Ethiopian women’s participation in public life.

Building on an academically peer-reviewed methodology and CIR’s published lexicon of 2,058 inflammatory keywords, the research analysed comments on popular and influential YouTube channels and TikTok accounts in Ethiopia, across four languages: Amharic, Afaan Oromo, Tigrigna, and English.

The research looked at hate targets based on Ethiopia’s definition of hate speech, which recognises ethnicity, religion, race, gender, or disability.

Survivors and subject matter experts working on women’s and girl’s rights, gender-based violence, and online safety, provided essential context and insight into the findings in workshops and meetings.

Investigators found that abuse faced by women included gendered stereotypes and criticisms related to women’s roles in society.

The research also uncovered trends in intersectional hate speech, showing that hate speech doesn’t simply target women and girls in a vacuum.

Political events and internal conflicts fuel www.info-res.org ethnic and gendered hate speech, while religious influences underpin much of the rhetoric used to discredit and demonise women.

The research shows that gendered roles also limit the active participation of men and boys online. Female and male content creators face distinct types of abuse: women are objectified, excluded, and ridiculed, while men are attacked for perceived weakness, lack of masculinity, or for supporting gender equality.

Notably, researchers found that men frequently insult other men and women with language that objectifies women’s bodies, further stigmatising women.

As a result, women not only experience gender-based violence firsthand but also become central to its perpetuation, used as both targets and symbols within abuse. Overall, CIR found more politicised hate on YouTube, while significant hate speech and objectification were observed on TikTok.

This study reveals that existing moderation practices are not sufficiently keeping women and girls, as well as other identity groups in Ethiopia, safe.

With the recent changes to content moderation policies on platforms like X and Meta, workshop participants included in this study expressed concerns that online spaces would become increasingly polarised and more vulnerable to the spread of more mis/disinformation.

CIR has been working to understand and address these issues through research, workshops, and a conference held in Addis Ababa in May 2024.

Similar to earlier research on other platforms, hate speech on TikTok and YouTube has real-world consequences, and the persistent and misguided view that the online space is separate from the ‘real world’ must be overcome.

 “What happens online does not stay online. In Ethiopia, online hate speech has already had lethal consequences.

We have seen how the doxing of individuals, particularly during the Tigray conflict, resulted in real-world violence and even killings,” said Felicity Mulford, Research Manager at CIR. This research is important in filling the information gap in the evolving challenges of TFGBV in Ethiopia’s digital landscape.

By ethionegari@gmail.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *