How Piracy Hurts Emerging Filmmakers

By Demeke Kebede

Making a film takes a long time, often years. It starts small: an idea, a script written late at night, a few people who believe in the story. Then comes the scramble to borrow money, find investors, gather actors and locations, and build a crew.

Then the film comes out, and sometimes within hours, someone has copied it, uploaded it and started passing it around without permission. To the viewer, it’s just another film online. To the filmmaker, it can determine whether they make another one or quit.

We usually talk about piracy in terms of copyright and the losses suffered by big media or production companies. But the effect on emerging filmmakers, the people still trying to get a foothold in the industry, gets far less attention.

A large studio can absorb the impact of a pirated release. It has other productions, distribution deals and several income streams. An emerging filmmaker often has none of that. One film may represent years of preparation and nearly everything they have. It isn’t only a product. It’s a bet on a career.

So when that film is pirated, the damage goes beyond lost sales. The filmmaker may not recover their costs, pay the crew or fund the next project. Writers, editors, sound engineers, costume and makeup artists, musicians and production assistants all depend on the film earning money. The producer struggles to recover the investment, the crew waits longer to be paid, an investor decides independent film is too risky, and a young director takes a job outside the industry. Piracy takes money from a film, but it can also take away the chance to make the next one.

This is especially true in emerging film industries, where money is already hard to find and filmmakers often have no back catalogue to lean on.

Picture a young Ethiopian filmmaker who spends months raising money for a film through savings, family support, small investors or a loan. They pay for the crew, equipment and locations, and release the film to a warm response. But before they’ve earned back a birr, a pirated copy appears online. It spreads to websites, social media and messaging groups, and then people who never paid copy and share it again. Thousands of people have now seen the film, but thousands of views don’t mean thousands of legitimate transactions.

That’s the core problem: piracy separates watching from paying. People consume the work while the person who made it receives little or nothing.

It gets worse when piracy is treated as harmless. Many people think sharing a pirated film simply saves money, or that if it’s already online, nobody is really hurt. But somebody made that film. A writer spent months on the story, a director took the risk of putting it on screen, and producers put money on the line. The file may be easy to copy. The work behind it wasn’t easy to make.

Technology cuts both ways. The same digital shift that lets a filmmaker reach an audience without owning a television station or cinema chain has also made copying quick and cheap. One unauthorised upload can become hundreds of copies, and taking down one link doesn’t touch the rest. An independent creator has almost no chance of monitoring them all. Nor is this only a film problem: music, photography, online courses, podcasts and books are affected too. As more African creators move into digital production, the stakes keep rising.

There’s another loss that’s easy to miss. Legitimate platforms show creators who is watching and where demand exists, which helps shape future productions and investment. Piracy moves much of that audience activity outside the system. The viewers are still there, but the creator sees neither the money nor the data.

None of this means everyone who watches pirated content wants to hurt someone. Often, people simply can’t easily find or afford a legitimate option, so punishment alone won’t solve the problem. People need legal options that are easy to find, fairly priced and convenient. Local creators need ways to reach audiences without unnecessary barriers. Platforms and rights holders need to make content available where viewers actually are. Enforcement also has to keep pace, through faster takedowns, stronger cooperation with platforms and greater public awareness.

Still, the biggest change may need to happen in how people think about it. Piracy isn’t just getting something for free. It’s taking value out of a creative economy. When someone buys a cinema ticket or subscribes to a legitimate platform, part of that money can return to the people who made the film. It helps recover costs, pay the crew and finance what comes next: a new director’s second film, an unknown actor’s first major role, work for dozens of young professionals, or a story that otherwise would never have been told.

If emerging filmmakers keep investing their money, time and talent only to watch others copy and profit from the result, some will eventually stop. Investors may become more cautious, companies may scale back, and young talent may move into other careers. Audiences may not notice right away. There will simply be fewer films. Fewer new voices. Fewer stories.

That’s why this isn’t only a fight about copyright or corporate revenue. It’s about whether new creators can build sustainable careers at all.

From behind a screen, piracy can look victimless. But behind every pirated film is someone’s work, someone’s investment and, often, someone’s hope of making the next one. Protecting that work isn’t just about what has already been created. It’s about making sure the next generation still has a reason, and a way, to create.

By ethionegari@gmail.com

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *